Veterans Health Administration:

Better Data and Evaluation Could Help Improve Physician Staffing, Recruitment, and Retention Strategies

GAO-18-124: Published: Oct 19, 2017. Publicly Released: Oct 19, 2017.

Additional Materials:

Contact:

Debra A. Draper
(202) 512-7114
draperd@gao.gov

 

Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800
youngc1@gao.gov

Does the Veterans Health Administration have enough doctors to keep up with veterans' growing health care needs? It can't be sure.

VHA knows the number of doctors it employs (over 11,000), but it doesn’t know how many contract physicians and physician trainees (e.g., medical residents) are used to meet its staffing needs. And although VHA uses multiple strategies to support the hiring and retention of physicians—including financial incentives and a physician training program—it hasn't evaluated their effectiveness.

We recommended that VHA develop a process to track all physicians, and evaluate its recruitment and retention strategies.

 

Photo of the Department of Veterans Affairs headquarters.

Photo of the Department of Veterans Affairs headquarters.

Additional Materials:

Contact:

Debra A. Draper
(202) 512-7114
draperd@gao.gov

 

Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800
youngc1@gao.gov

What GAO Found

The Veterans Health Administration (VHA), within the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), has opportunities to improve staffing, recruitment, and retention strategies for physicians that it identified as a priority for staffing, or mission-critical. For 2016, the top five physician mission-critical occupations were primary care, mental health, gastroenterology, orthopedic surgery, and emergency medicine. Specifically, GAO identified the following issues:

Incomplete information on number of physicians. VHA is unable to accurately count the total number of physicians who provide care in its VA medical centers (VAMC). VHA has data on the number of mission-critical physicians it employs (more than 11,000) and that provide services on a fee-basis (about 2,800). However, VHA lacks data on the number of contract physicians and physician trainees. Five of the six VAMCs in GAO's review used contract physicians or physician trainees to meet their staffing needs, but VHA has no information on the extent to which VAMCs nationwide use these arrangements.

VAMCs' Use of Contract Physicians, Fee-Basis Physicians, and Physician Trainees for Mission-Critical Physician Occupations at the Six VAMCs We Reviewed, as of March 31, 2017

VAMCs' Use of Contract Physicians, Fee-Basis Physicians, and Physician Trainees for Mission-Critical Physician Occupations at the Six VAMCs We Reviewed, as of March 31, 2017 img data-cke-saved-src=

Inconsistent productivity data. VHA measures productivity for some mission-critical physician occupations; however, mental health departments receive conflicting sets of productivity metrics from two VHA offices—the Office of Productivity, Efficiency, and Staffing and the Office of Mental Health Operations. VHA officials told us the two offices use differing data to serve different purposes, and acknowledged that while information on how to interpret the two sets of productivity data is available, VAMC officials may find the data confusing.

Lack of a comprehensive evaluation of its recruitment and retention strategies. VHA has not evaluated the effectiveness of its physician recruitment and retention strategies. One such strategy—hiring physician trainees—is weakened by ineffectual hiring practices, such as delaying employment offers until graduation. VHA's strategies could be strengthened by comprehensively evaluating the causes of recruitment and retention difficulties and identifying effective solutions.

Why GAO Did This Study

Physicians serve an integral role in VHA's mission of providing care to the nation's veterans. VHA hires more than 2,800 mission-critical physicians annually. Yet, physicians have consistently been identified by VHA as a critical staffing priority due to recruitment and retention concerns.

The explanatory statement accompanying the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2016 directed GAO to review VHA's physician workforce. This report addresses: for the mission-critical physicians, (1) VHA data on how many physicians provide care, and (2) the extent VHA measures physician workload and productivity; and for all physicians, (3) what evaluations have been done on the effectiveness of its recruitment and retention strategies. GAO reviewed VHA documentation, such as policies and guidance, personnel data and workload measures. GAO interviewed officials from VHA Central Office, and six VAMCs and their corresponding regional offices. GAO selected the VAMCs for variation in location, facility complexity, and physician staffing levels.

What GAO Recommends

GAO makes five recommendations, including that VA develop a process to count all physicians, provide guidance on productivity measurement, and evaluate its physician recruitment and retention strategies. VA concurred with four of the five recommendations, but not with the one to accurately count all physicians, stating that its workforce assessment tools are sufficient. However, GAO maintains that this is essential for effective workforce planning, as described in the report.

For more information, contact Debra A. Draper at (202) 512-7114 or draperd@gao.gov.

Recommendations for Executive Action

  1. Status: Open

    Comments: VHA did not concur with this recommendation. Until completion of the action items, this recommendation will remain open.

    Recommendation: The Undersecretary for Health should develop and implement a process to accurately count all physicians providing care at each medical center, including physicians who are not employed by VHA. (Recommendation 1)

    Agency Affected: Department of Veterans Affairs: Veterans Health Administration

  2. Status: Open

    Comments: VHA concurred with this recommendation. In November 2017, the Executive in Charge for VHA signed the Specialty Care workgroup charter and anticipates implementing staffing models for emergency medicine, gastroenterology, and orthopedics by October 2018. Until completion of the action items, this recommendation will remain open.

    Recommendation: The Undersecretary for Health should develop and issue guidance to the VAMCs on determining appropriate staffing levels for all mission-critical physician occupations. (Recommendation 2)

    Agency Affected: Department of Veterans Affairs: Veterans Health Administration

  3. Status: Closed - Implemented

    Comments: In response to our finding, VHA leadership determined that although facilities could use Mental Health Onboard Clinical data for individualized productivity monitoring, the Office of Productivity, Efficiency, and Staffing (OPES) would be the official source issuing productivity data for physicians and that their data should be used for making productivity comparisons with external organizations. VHA communicated this decision to all field and program offices through an email in March 2018 and by updating their internal webpage with clarifications about their data. The FAQ on their internal website specifically clarifies methodological differences between the OPES and Mental Health data sets by explaining, for example, that the OPES measures do not include mental health imputed values, and that they are consistent with external methodologies and benchmarks. The VHA email, as well as a previously issued memorandum, guide staff to use the OPES data for external comparisons and as the official source of productivity data, and to use the Mental Health data for individualized productivity monitoring when needed.

    Recommendation: The Undersecretary for Health should ensure that when multiple offices issue similar productivity data on physician occupations, any methodological differences are clearly communicated and guidance is provided on how to interpret and reconcile the data. (Recommendation 3)

    Agency Affected: Department of Veterans Affairs: Veterans Health Administration

  4. Status: Open

    Comments: VHA concurred with this recommendation. VHA is working to develop the necessary capacity to enable a system-wide method for sharing information about physician trainees to help fill vacancies. VHA anticipates having this system in place by the end of fiscal year 2019. Until completion of the action items, this recommendation will remain open.

    Recommendation: The Undersecretary for Health should establish a system-wide method to share information about physician trainees to help fill vacancies across VAMCs. (Recommendation 4)

    Agency Affected: Department of Veterans Affairs: Veterans Health Administration

  5. Status: Open

    Comments: VHA concurred with this recommendation. In its response to our report, VHA stated that it is in the process of completing a review of physician recruitment, relocation, and retention incentives by specialty as well as a comparison of salary data for local markets. Beginning in October 2017, the VHA Office of Workforce Management and Consulting (WMC) partnered with the internal Partnered Evidence-based Policy Resource Center to evaluate and recommend a systematic approach to allocating workforce management resources such as the Education Debt Reduction Program and incentive utilization. VHA expects to complete this review by September 2018. Until completion of the action items, this recommendation will remain open.

    Recommendation: The Undersecretary for Health should conduct a comprehensive, system-wide evaluation of the physician recruitment and retention strategies used by VAMCs to determine their overall effectiveness, identify and implement improvements, ensure coordination across VHA offices, and establish an ongoing monitoring process. (Recommendation 5)

    Agency Affected: Department of Veterans Affairs: Veterans Health Administration

 

Explore the full database of GAO's Open Recommendations »

Oct 3, 2018

Sep 28, 2018

Sep 27, 2018

Sep 13, 2018

Sep 5, 2018

Sep 4, 2018

Jul 31, 2018

Jul 24, 2018

Jul 19, 2018

Jun 26, 2018

Looking for more? Browse all our products here