Federal Oversight of Electricity Markets and Infrastructure
Electricity is essential to modern lifeproviding many services to households and a key resource to U.S. businesses. Production of electricity can lead to environmental concerns including air and water pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and waste associated with the burning of coal or from spent nuclear fuel. The national electricity system, which was built up over decades, faces a number of challenges, including reliability and security concerns.
Much of the nations electricity is produced by private companies at privately-owned power plants, and is sold to consumers in retail markets that are regulated by state and/or local governments. However, the federal government has several important roles in the electricity industryas a regulator, as a driver of electricity policy, overseeing electricitys environmental impacts, and as an owner of electricity infrastructure.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) serves as the principal federal regulator of electricity markets and transmission. In recent years, FERC has taken steps to increase the role of markets by, among other things:
- Encouraging the development of independent transmission operators such as Regional Transmission Organizations (RTO). (Figure 1 shows the RTOs operating in the United States.)
- Approving plans for the creation of independently operated, centralized markets
- Taking steps to monitor the competiveness of those markets
Figure 1: U.S. Regional Transmission Organizations
Concerns over the long-term availability and price of domestic and international fuel sources, and broader national policy issues such as climate change, have increased the national focus on aspects of electricity policy. The proportion of electricity generated using various fuel sources has been a consistent area of interest to stakeholders involved in questions of national electricity policy. (Figure 2 provides a forecast of how electricity production is expected to change in the future)
Figure 2: EIA Forecast of Electricity Generation, by Fuel Source
Key policy issues pursued in recent years:
- Development of proposed national policies to address climate change, which could affect how electricity is produced and its price.
- Incentives for different fuel sources for electricity.
- Efforts to promote renewable energy and consideration of how to operate transmission grids in order to accommodate the increased use of renewable.
- Impacts of changing fuel prices and regulatory changes on electricity supplies.
- Increased emphasis on real-time pricing of electricity and other forms of demand responsea way to potentially reduce electricity demand by paying consumers to reduce their usage.
Electricitys Impact on the Environment
Production of electricity can have important impacts on the environment. Producing electricity from fossil fuels can result in air pollution, water impacts, solid waste, and emissions of greenhouse gasses. Some of these impacts are subject to federal regulation and some have been the subject of legislative review. Producing electricity using nuclear power results in radioactive waste that must be stored, but the federal government has not yet completed a waste storage facility and it has been sued by utilities seeking to recover claimed damages resulting from the delay. Efforts to develop a waste repository at Yucca Mountain, in Nevada, have been the subject of ongoing debate. Key areas of GAO examination include:
- Regulations to address environmental impacts from electricity generation
- Efforts to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases from fossil-fueled power plants
- Efforts of the Department of Energy and others to develop a waste repository at Yucca Mountain
- The use of water at electricity plants
Owner of Electricity Infrastructure
The federal government is the largest owner of electricity generating capacity and owns significant transmission assets in the United States. Development of these resources was initially pursued as part of efforts to provide electricity to rural areas and as part of flood control and irrigation efforts. These electricity assets are managed by the following federal entities:
- Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) (Figure 3 shows TVAs service area and key generating facilities.
- Bonneville Power Administration (BPA)
- Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)
- Southeastern Power Administration (SEPA)
- Southwestern Power Administration (SWPA)
GAO has examined the operation of these entities, their performance, and other issues.)
Figure 3: TVA Service Area and Key Electricity Generating Facilities
GAO-12-635: Published: Jul 17, 2012. Publicly Released: Aug 16, 2012.
It is uncertain how power companies may respond to four key Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulations, but available information suggests companies may retrofit most coal-fueled generating units with controls to reduce pollution, and that 2 to 12 percent of coal-fueled capacity may be retired. Some regions may see more significant levels of retirements. For example, one study examined 11 s...
GAO-12-107: Published: Oct 31, 2011. Publicly Released: Dec 1, 2011.
The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), the nation's largest public power provider, is a self-financing, federal electric utility with annual revenues of about $11 billion. TVA has financed large capital investments mostly by issuing debt and is subject to a $30 billion debt ceiling imposed by the TVA Act. TVA is governed by a 9-member Board. Within an affirmation requirement for the TVA Board, the...
GAO-11-117: Published: Jan 12, 2011. Publicly Released: Jan 12, 2011.
The electric industry is increasingly incorporating information technology (IT) systems into its operations as part of nationwide efforts--commonly referred to as smart grid--to improve reliability and efficiency. There is concern that if these efforts are not implemented securely, the electric grid could become more vulnerable to attacks and loss of services. To address this concern, the Energy I...
GAO-08-987: Published: Sep 22, 2008. Publicly Released: Sep 26, 2008.
In 1999, as a part of federal efforts to restructure the electricity industry, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) began encouraging the voluntary formation of Regional Transmission Organizations (RTO)--independent entities to manage regional networks of electric transmission lines. FERC oversees six RTOs that cover part or all of 35 states and D.C. and serve over half of U.S. electric...
GAO-04-844: Published: Aug 13, 2004. Publicly Released: Sep 13, 2004.
The efficient and reliable functioning of the more than $200 billion electric industry is vital to the lives of all Americans. As demonstrated in the 2003 black- out in the Northeast and the 2001 energy crisis in the West, changes in the cost and availability of electricity can have significant impacts on consumers and the national economy. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) supports...
GAO-20-380SP: Published: Feb 26, 2020. Publicly Released: Feb 26, 2020.
Cyberattacks and natural disasters can pose risks to the electric grid across the country, potentially resulting in blackouts and other disruptions to daily life. Nuclear microreactors are an emerging technology that could help affected areas get back up and running faster. Compact and mobile, fully-assembled microreactors could be transported by rail, truck, or plane to wherever they are needed...
GAO-19-332: Published: Aug 26, 2019. Publicly Released: Sep 25, 2019.
The nationâ€™s electric grid is becoming more vulnerable to cyberattacksâ€”particularly those involving industrial control systems that support grid operations. Recent federal assessments indicate that cyberattacks could cause widespread power outages in the United States, but the scale of such outages is uncertain. The Department of Energy (DOE) plays a key role in helping address cybersecurity...
GAO-18-675T: Published: Jul 24, 2018. Publicly Released: Jul 24, 2018.
The Strategic Petroleum Reserve, managed by the Department of Energy, is the nation's stockpile of emergency oil stored in salt caverns along the Gulf Coast. This testimony covers our May 2018 report, which found that DOE may need less of the reserve's storage space by 2027, after congressionally mandated oil sales. While DOE planned to explore some options for the excess capacityâ€”i.e., closin...
GAO-18-477: Published: May 30, 2018. Publicly Released: Jun 28, 2018.
The Strategic Petroleum Reserve, managed by the Department of Energy, exists to minimize the effects of disruptions in the supply of petroleum products. As of March 2018, it held about 665 million barrels of crude oil. How big should the reserve be? A review by the Department didn't determine an optimal size and did not fully consider factors including Changes in current and future market condit...
GAO-18-131: Published: Dec 7, 2017. Publicly Released: Dec 7, 2017.
To ensure there will be enough electricity from power plants to meet customers' future needs, some U.S. electricity grid operators use "capacity markets." In capacity markets, power plant owners are paid for committing that their plants will be available to provide electricity during a specified future time period, encouraging them to build new power plants and retain existing ones. We reviewed t...
GAO-17-343: Published: Mar 23, 2017. Publicly Released: Apr 24, 2017.
The Tennessee Valley Authority, the nation's largest public power provider, provides electricity to more than 9 million customers. It raises billions in revenue but also issues bonds to finance its large capital investments (though it is subject to a $30-billion debt limit). The TVA plans to reduce its debt by about $4 billion by 2023 by increasing rates and reducing expenses; it also plans to el...
GAO-17-142: Published: Feb 13, 2017. Publicly Released: Mar 15, 2017.
Rooftop solar panels, batteries, and smart thermostats, installed in residences, can allow customers to generate and store electricity, as well as manage its use. These and other technologies can make electricity grids operate more efficiently and provide other benefitsâ€”such as cleaner generation of electricity. However, if deployed without regard to grid conditions, these technologies could pr...
GAO-17-153: Published: Jan 25, 2017. Publicly Released: Feb 24, 2017.
The nation's electricity grid faces potential threats from natural disasters and deliberate attacks. We looked at the federal government's efforts to enhance the gridâ€™s resilienceâ€”its ability to adapt to changing conditions and withstand and recover from potentially disruptive events (such as the loss of power lines). The 27 federal efforts to enhance grid resilience focused on enhancing awar...
GAO-17-43: Published: Nov 10, 2016. Publicly Released: Nov 17, 2016.
Tribal nations hold considerable energy resources thatâ€”when developedâ€”can improve tribal well-being and long-term economic success. However, a number of factorsâ€”including a complex federal regulatory framework that involves multiple agenciesâ€”have hampered development. A collaborative federal approach to helping tribes achieve their energy goals is important. But we found that federal init...
GAO-16-487: Published: Sep 8, 2016. Publicly Released: Sep 8, 2016.
The Department of Defense (DOD) has emphasized working with private developers using a variety of alternative financing mechanismsâ€”that is, agreements with private developers to pay back the costs of the projects over timeâ€”to develop renewable energy projects greater than 1 megawatt. According to DOD officials, DOD works with private developers because doing so gives DOD several advantages. Fo...